Tuesday, May 27, 2008

What do Georgian Troops Think about the Iraq War?

Recently, the Georgian Times published an article on a poll recently conducted by GORBI of Georgian Troops in Iraq. According to the article, this is the first poll conducted amongst these soldiers.

The article highlights that troops continue to have very positive feelings towards their tenure in Iraq and agree with Saakashvili sending them there. According to the poll, 89% are satisfied with the current conditions and 93% are satisfied with their training.

This data may point to the professionalization of the Georgian army. Interestingly, according to a poll done by the Military Times (no ability to rate its quality) at the end of 2007, 80% of American troops, still say they are "somewhat" or "completely" satisfied with their jobs. This is despite the fact that now more than half of troops believe that America should not have gone to war.

Georgian citizens, however, like American citizens and unlike the Georgian troops generally do not support troop involvement in Iraq and often possess cynical views of America "buying cheap Georgian cannon fodder" type.

The article, however, opens several interesting research questions.

  • Why do Georgian troops have such a positive attitude towards serving in Iraq? I think there may be several unexpected answers to this question, which involve exposure to different troops (i.e. Americans and Brits) and the benefits and salaries these soldiers receive compared to what the receive back home. Or maybe, they just have the feeling that they are serving a useful purpose. Feedback welcome.
  • Interestingly, the questionnaire used by GORBI was a self-completion questionnaire. Our experience is that these type of questionnaires work poorly with Georgians, as there is no tradition of filling them out. We wonder how this worked with the Georgian troops.
If the GORBI dataset was publicly available, interesting analysis could be done there.

3 comments:

HansG said...

well, at the risk of a self-referential commenting game: self-completion questionnaires should work quite well with soldiers. If they have been trained in ANY NATO standards, they will be great at dealing with paperwork. (Seriously: weapons, ammunition, equipment, all this stuff has tremendous documentation needs.) I could imagine, though, that it somewhat overstates satisfaction.

Jonathan Kulick said...

I would question the characterization of the US military as overwhelmingly conservative and Republican. True of the officer corps, which is greatly outnumbered by the enlisted ranks, who look more or less like the general population. See mysterypollster.com/main/2006/06/update_ii_milit.html

AaronE said...

Jonathan,

I stand corrected. Excuse the over generalization.